Lesson 2: Caries Risk Assessment

 

Risk assessment is a technique used in health care to identify and to classify a patient according to his or her risk for developing a particular disease. It is used to customize treatment and prevention according to  individual need. In addition, risk assessment is an integral part in determining the most efficient allocation of resources during this time of increasing health care costs.   

Caries risk assessment is used to identify and to classify dental patients according to risk for developing dental caries ("cavities"). Since patients have varying degrees of susceptibility to developing caries, it follows that not all patients should be treated alike. Caries risk assessment is recognized by national and international dental organizations as representing one aspect of  the community standard of care practiced in dental clinics and private offices throughout  the U.S. and in other industrialized countries.   

 

The information in this lesson explores the following topics:

 
  • Epidemiology of dental caries

  • 2.Etiology and contributing factors

  • 3.Surgical and medical models of treatment
  • 4.Caries risk assessment as standard of care  

 

 

Background

Do you think of caries as an infection, like other bacterial diseases that can be passed from one person to another?

 

 

 

Ø

 

 

Epidemiology

Is caries a problem for everyone?

 

World Health Organization

http://www.who.int/oral_health/en/

 

During the past two decades, caries prevalence has decreased significantly among children and young adults in most industrialized countries, while the prevalence has increased in most developing countries” 

 

The WHO has declared the decrease in caries prevalence as one of the greatest public health successes in industrialized countries.

 

What is responsible for the success?

 

ü*Increased oral hygiene

ü*Fluoride toothpaste

ü*Fluoridated water

ü*Nutritional counseling

*üSchool-based preventive programs

 

 

 

Even though the overall prevalence of dental caries in the U.S. has decreased, certain segments of the population still suffer from the disease. Who's still getting cavities?

Children

Geriatric patients

Patients with systemic disease

 

 

 

Exploration Phase

Dental caries: Etiology

and Contributing Factors

 

  •  Work independently or in small groups to answer the following questions:

 

What causes caries?

 

1)      The formation of dental caries is influenced by many factors. List as many factors as you can, and group them into 2 – 3 categories.

Category:

Category:

Category:

 

2) What name would you give to each category?

 

 

See Concept Introduction

 

 

 

Models for the Treatment of Dental Caries

 

 

 

A surgical model for the treatment of any disease implies that surgery, or "cutting it out" is the primary method for treating the disease. A surgical model in dentistry implies that restoring the carious lesion (“cutting it out”), and the placement of a dental restoration ("filling") is the treatment of choice. 

A medical model, instead, addresses the cause and the contributing factors that might lead to disease.

 

3)      Based on the categories of factors that you idenitified above, try writing a sentence that could be a definition for a medical model for the treatment of dental caries.

See Concept Introduction

 

 

 

 

Based on the above exploration, consider the following questions:

 

  • üDo all patients with plaque develop caries?
  • üDo all patients who eat sweets develop caries?
  • üDo all patients with a high strep mutans level develop caries?

 

 

Application Phase

Caries Risk Assessment

 

4)  All people don’t experience caries at the same rate.  Based on the medical model that you defined above, try writing some parameters for how a patient might be identified and then categorized according to risk.

See Concept Introduction

 

 

 

Philosophy of Treatment

 

 

5) Based on the medical model, what are some treatment strategies, in addition to restorations, that might be employed to prevent future caries in a high-risk patient?

 

 

See Concept Introduction

 

 

 

References

  Leverett DH; Proskin HM; Featherstone JD; Adair SM; Eisenberg AD; Mundorff-Shrestha SA; Shields CP; Shaffer CL; Billings; RJ. Caries risk assessment in a longitudinal discrimination study.

J Dent Res 1993; (72)2: 538-43

 

Leverett DH; Featherstone JD; Proskin HM; Adair SM; Eisenberg AD; Mundorff-Shrestha SA; Shields CP; Shaffer CL; Billings; RJ. Caries risk assessment by a cross-sectional discrimination model. J Dent Res 1993; (72)2: 529-37

 

Rethman J. Trends in Preventive Care: Caries Risk Assessment and Indications for Sealants | http://www.ada.org/prof/resources/pubs/jada/reports/suppl_21century_03.pdf

White JM, Eakle S. Rationale and Treatment Approach in Minimally Invasive Dentistry | PDF File/105k